It will still be protected as a compensation pick in 2015 if we don't sign the guy we get in 2014. The new CBA changed it so that a pick is protected for two years instead of one.
Prior to AA getting the job, our system was ranked 28 overall out of 30. Less than two years later it was consensus top 3. People just need something to bitch about.
That had little to do with drafting and scouting? So you think they read d'Arnaud and Gose's names on a baseball america list and said "We have to have them"? The Jays had absolutely no leverage in the Phillies trade. That was completely to AA's credit. He didn't even get Gose in the Phillies trade either. He wanted Gose, but Gose had been traded to the Astros. He got d'Arnaud, Taylor, and Drabek who was a top 10 prospect in baseball at the time. He turned Taylor into Brett Wallace and Wallace into Gose. Not only did he get two guys he really wanted with the Phillies, he used the third chip, which was useless, and turned it into Gose through shrewd trades.
Every single team in the majors had the ability to acquire Type-A and Type-B free agents at the trade deadline and turn them into compensation picks, thus resulting in "significantly boosting" their farm. Yet nobody outside of the Jays and Rays did it to the extent that Anthopoulos did. So if not boosting the system from bottom 3 to top 3 in a year was a profound failure, it looks like more than 25 teams failed "profoundly", given that no team did what the Jays did while having all the same resources and ability to do so.
The Jays weren't the only ones to pass on Sale, two teams (Diamondbacks and Padres, both known for good farm systems) picked players prior the Sale pick that didn't even sign. The Jays offered 3M to Beede and he refused. The Yankees failed to sign Gerrit Cole in the 2008 draft, the Pirates failed to sign Appel in the 2011 draft, it happens to every single team. When the guy doesn't want to sign, he won't sign. The Jays gave Bickford an offer of 2.9M, a guy who was ranked in the 40s coming into the draft. His price tag was 4.2M, it's ridiculous to look at this as a failure. The Jays did exactly what they should have done, they got a better pick next year.
It's gotten to a hilarious point how many of you think you know how to do AA's job better than he does.