Why do you keep beating the Melky drum, as though getting him at 3 years/$42M was some sort of coup for the White Sox? That's not a dollar figure that I'd have been comfortable with for Melky, and I'm much happier with Martin at 5/$82. Martin is the clear better player of the two, at a much more crucial position. Melky hits for average, that's about it, he's an extremely sub-par defender at the easiest position on the field.