Well when the question of the thread is whether or not he can stick, presumably the question would be can he stick long term.
Since there more to long term thinking than a current hot streak with the bat, and defense is a thing that helps win ball games... and he sux at, regardless if it's 1b, LF or anywhere .... and it's not possible to sustain his current hot streak, it bears mentioning in people's arguments that don't see him as a long term piece, along g with their reasoning as to why.
Seeing 1 person mount an argument and then 75 people say "I agree" or " I disagree" isn't exactly meaningful discourse.