Biggest surprise: Jake Arrieta
Biggest disappointment: Danny Salazar
Between these two dick-bags, I probably have the biggest SP disappointment and the biggest SP surprise of 2014. I guess it kind of cancels out. Salazar's peripherals are still pretty f***ing intriguing, and I don't think 80 innings in 2014 is enough to say "hur durr he's too hittable". It might be a small fix that he'll be able to make, and/or he might just be getting stupid unlucky.
Biggest MiLB surprise: Stroman, Harvey, Renfroe, Manaea, and Nick Williams haven't really surprised but they've done virtually everything I could have realistically hoped they would this year. Getting Raimel Tapia at the end of the first round this summer was also a nice surprise.
Biggest MiLB disappointment: I was bummed when the Yankees gave up on Jose Ramirez as a starting pitcher.