Fat L my dude.
Ohtani is a 150wRC+ hitter AND a 3.28 ERA starter that pitched 120 innings.
Vlad is a 170wRC+ hitter that plays first base every day.
Vlad is the better hitter, Ohtani is the better and more valuable all around player. If Ohtani and Vlad swapped teams at the beginning of the year, the Jays are likely in a wildcard spot RIGHT NOW.