Part of the problem is Gibbers constant absenteeism. If you don't have time for a league, you shouldn't be in it. People send him trade offers that he ignores for weeks or months, then suddenly you pull off trades with him on players that were never ever trade blocked. I don't see collusion per se, but what I do see is favourtism, a willingness to take a subpar return as a favour to a friend you know in person, absenteeism, an excess of NA players for an extended period of team, a complete unwillingness to ever field a competitive team over a multi-year period, and generally a s***** attitude. If you are going to have a crappy rebuilding team, be present, make moves, build towards something. He has not done any of those things, and the rope has been long.
I don't want to hear "oh sorry I was away from email for two weeks." This is 2017, we all have mobile apps, we all have smartphones, we all have email at our fingertips most of the day. If you can't fulfill basic communication requirements, this league isn't for you. It's time we hand this team over to an owner who actually intends on winning some day, and who actually responds to messages in a reasonable period of time.