I cherry picked two pitchers? I picked two random pitchers, I can go on though, Shane Greene, Homer Bailey who missed time due to injury, Jose Fernandez, James Paxton etc are all better pitchers.
Every good MLB staff needs workhorses, that doesnt mean those workhorses are all average or better starters. 3.71 is solid, the 4.2 from the previous year wasnt, nor was the XFIP from either of the two seasons here. I dont know what stat im cherry picking, I keep giving him credit for being a workhorse, that again doesnt mean he's a top 75 pitcher. You only mentioned Innings, ERA and Wins ( not sure why would even bring this up once)