Absolutely not, I'm 100% with you. For whatever reason Price is falling behind hitters and unable to put away the guys he gets ahead. At least for the past 3 starts.
Maybe Gibbons just didn't want Price to pitch Game 5 at all, Texas has hurt him before and didn't fair well in the first game. Use this as an excuse to keep him out.
I feel so bad for Dickey, he was doing an amazing job in an elimination game and gets pulled before he can even get a chance to get the W. That's f***ed up man.