I know you can do this with any draft, but it's more interesting and prescient since JP Ricciardi has actually said he regretted drafting Ricky.
Who else could he have taken though? (Bold on superior or amusing names)
2005 MLB amateur draft:
PICK PLAYER POS TEAM SCHOOL/HOMETOWN
1 Justin Upton SS Arizona Diamondbacks Great Bridge HS (VA)
2 Alex Gordon 3B Kansas City Royals Nebraska
3 Jeffrey Clement C Seattle Mariners USC
4 Ryan Zimmerman 3B Washington Nationals Virginia
5 Ryan Braun 3B Milwaukee Brewers Miami
6 Ricardo Romero LHP Toronto Blue Jays CS Fullerton
7 Troy Tulowitski SS Colorado Rockies Long Beach
8 Wade Townsend RHP Tampa Bay Devil Rays Rice
9 Michael Pelfrey RHP New York Mets Wichita St
10 Cameron Maybin CF Detroit Tigers T C Roberson HS (NC)
11 Andrew McCutchen CF Pittsburgh Pirates Fort Meade HS (FL)
12 Jay Bruce CF Cincinnati Reds West Brook HS (TX)
13 Brandon Snyder C Baltimore Orioles Westfield HS (VA)
14 Trevor Crowe CF Cleveland Indians Arizona
15 Lance Broadway RHP Chicago White Sox TCU
16 Christopher Volstad RHP Florida Marlins Palm Beach Gardens HS (FL)
17 Carl Henry SS New York Yankees Putnam City HS (OK)
18 Cesar Carrillo RHP San Diego Padres Miami
19 John Mayberry RF Texas Rangers Stanford
20 Mark Pawelek LHP Chicago Cubs Springville HS (UT)
21 Clifton Pennington SS Oakland Athletics Texas A&M
23 Jacoby Ellsbury CF Boston Red Sox Oregon St
24 Brian Bogusevic LHP Houston Astros Tulane
25 Matthew Albidrez-Garza RHP Minnesota Twins Fresno St
26 Craig Hansen RHP Boston Red Sox St. Johns
27 Joseph Devine RHP Atlanta Braves North Carolina St
28 Colby Rasmus CF St. Louis Cardinals Russell County HS (AL)
30 James Greene SS St. Louis Cardinals Georgia Tech