What's Gibby supposed to do. The situation called for a lefty and Loup had pitched two days in a row. He should have gone to Rasmussen.
If Rasmussen isn't fit to pitch in a close game, then we have three such relievers (Rasmussen, Jenkins, Redmond) which is two too many and falls on AA. I would have pulled Rasmussen after hitting Jeter though, that's my only gripe.