Jump to content
Jays Centre
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Posted
Shouldn't they be trying to add players who are actually good? The obvious concern here is that they think Martin and Russell are good.

 

well for one, they haven't even signed russell. so I am not even worried about him. The way they are looking to add talent right now is through the draft. Which so far, it looks like they have had success. They are using the free agent market to sign small complementary pieces that won't take away roles from the young studs. they have to see what they got, and they're not going to have as much of an idea what they have by bringing in free agent 2nd and 3rd liners that the kids would be playing behind.

 

And just because they signed Martin, doesn't mean they think he's GOOD. It means they think there is a role on this team for him in Toronto. Which there may be, as there is a definitive lack of toughness on this team. A line with Komarov / Laich / Martin might be a good fit.

Old-Timey Member
Posted
Panthers and Preds having really good offseasons.

Panthers have fully embraced analytics I love it.

Old-Timey Member
Posted
well for one, they haven't even signed russell. so I am not even worried about him. The way they are looking to add talent right now is through the draft. Which so far, it looks like they have had success. They are using the free agent market to sign small complementary pieces that won't take away roles from the young studs. they have to see what they got, and they're not going to have as much of an idea what they have by bringing in free agent 2nd and 3rd liners that the kids would be playing behind.

 

And just because they signed Martin, doesn't mean they think he's GOOD. It means they think there is a role on this team for him in Toronto. Which there may be, as there is a definitive lack of toughness on this team. A line with Komarov / Laich / Martin might be a good fit.

 

Why would you give Martin a 4 year deal and 10 mil. if you don't think he's good? And if you are signing someone who's bad at hockey for that contract just to throw hits around then I've got even worse news...

Old-Timey Member
Posted

And if they think Matt Martin is good at hockey some talent evaluation obviously went amiss here.

 

So in summary,

- The Leafs think Matt Martin is good at hockey and give him 10 mill.

- The Leafs think Matt Martin is bad at hockey and give him 10 mill. to fill a tough guy role.

 

Neither of these are good.

Posted
Panthers have fully embraced analytics I love it.

Love the Marchessault signing but Reimer, Demers, and Yandle signings are too much for too long.

Posted
I shouldn't have said they don't think he's good. They think he is good at a specific playing style that will help the team. As for the term, I think it's pretty inconsequential. They can buy him out at any time.
Old-Timey Member
Posted
And if they think Matt Martin is good at hockey some talent evaluation obviously went amiss here.

 

So in summary,

- The Leafs think Matt Martin is good at hockey and give him 10 mill.

- The Leafs think Matt Martin is bad at hockey and give him 10 mill. to fill a tough guy role.

 

Neither of these are good.

 

Logan Stanley.

 

*mic drop*

Old-Timey Member
Posted
Yeah that was bad too.

 

I'm just kidding, King.

 

Your Leafs points are spot on. It was an egregious move to give Martin $10MM.

Posted

Again for reference, here is my latest hockey GAR for last year and previous seasons. I have calculated about $0.4M/GAR.

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1xKtPSEkw0nMMF-uXAsXHIz-cUKjxv8OYyiVJYOUbifU/edit?usp=sharing

 

- Weber was 42nd in the league (21 GAR, $8.4M) and 2nd best Dman behind Giordano last year while Subban was replacement (-0.08) (!). Subban was much better in 2014 though (19 GAR, $7.6M).

 

- Loui Eriksson (32.2, $12.9M) was second to only Ovechkin (36.3, $14.5M) in GAR last year. Could be a nice deal for Canucks.

 

- Hall (13.7, $5.5M) was 135th in the league and Larsson (6.2, $2.5M) was 336th.

 

- Matt Martin had 5.4 GAR ($2.2M worth) last year.

 

- Connor McDavid was the best player in the league by rate stats!

Posted
Nothing wrong with the Martin signing at all he is the guy I wanted slightly too much money maybe 500k / year and one to many years. The deal for Anderson was solid and we haven't even signed Russel ( I hope they don't )
Posted
Leafs signed Roman Polak for one year. definitely not signing Russell now.

 

2 more 2nd rounders at the deadline please

Community Moderator
Posted
Al Strachan tweeting about Tavares coming home to Toronto. You idiots get to spend the next two years penciling him into your hypothetical lineups before he ultimately signs an extension in New York!
Posted
Al Strachan tweeting about Tavares coming home to Toronto. You idiots get to spend the next two years penciling him into your hypothetical lineups before he ultimately signs an extension in New York!

 

But our team will be that much better in 2 years that he'd have to sign! /sarcasm

Posted
Al Strachan tweeting about Tavares coming home to Toronto. You idiots get to spend the next two years penciling him into your hypothetical lineups before he ultimately signs an extension in New York!

 

Why the need to call names?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Blue Jays community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...