Dude, seriously, this is the issue I have with stats... This is not just directed at you, but you are the epitome of this... Did you ever actually watch a Jays game from 2013-2015 or did you just read about them on Fangraphs? Apart from the ball that fell in between him and JB in the ALCS, he was an excellent defensive player at 2b and SS. He really helped the pitching staff and in turn the team. He was not supposed to be starter, he was a utility back up. When the starter was hurt, which happened to be a lot, he came in and did a serviceable job as a back up utility IF and provided plus D.. He could lay down a bunt or make contact if required.
He was what he was.. No one is saying they think he was Roberto Alomar.. When he started deteriorating, we cut bait, as we should have... But he was good at what he was there to do...