You are missing John Schneider's point about not been given the opportunity to appeal. The home plate ump did NOT signal that the player from home scored as he crossed the plate. If the umpire would have signalled that a run scored (which is his job) then the Jays would naturally appeal. They were denied that because the ump didn't perform his function.
Jays claim several players were asking for an appeal but the umps waved off the run and instructed them to go to the dugout and that they would discuss. Ostensibly denying the opportunity to appeal.
How is doubling off the runner at first base throwing to the wrong base? Also the runner at third base did not tag up yet the run still counted. You dont see why this would cause confusion?
The Blue Jays way:
Play competitive ball for the next 13 games against NYY, Crapsox and the Rays.
Then proceed to crap the bed against sub .500 teams the rest of the way.
He really is far too selective for my tastes. I wonder if somebody said something to him about Pitch selection and trying to Keyhole a pitch? The guy really has to swing a lot more.
The fact that Max got there with over 500 fewer innings pitched than Verlander should tell you all you all you need to know with respect to who was the best of their generation.