I'd rather have Donaldson hit leadoff. You could probably move Tulo up to the 3 hole now pushing Edwin down to 4. Tulo's s*** bag days seem to be behind him.
Going down to Triple-A is not the end of the world. That's the place to work on his mechanics not here. Hutchison deserves the opurtunity quite frankly.
I guess I will go with Barney. If he doesn't play for reasons unknown I wil take Donaldson. I like Pillar on days like this but its hard to imagine him being able to hit Sale's slider.