Id rather have the great stat guy with good stuff than the mediocre stat guy with excellent stuff.
For example Id rather have Stroman than Sanchez when they were both in AA.
Forgot Reyes since he hasnt pitched yet but yes hes good. It sounds like youre talking more about ceiling though. Kind of a expected outcome and stats vs. ceiling and scouting argument.
They all have the velo. Secondary pitches are hard to scout, as is future command. Stats certainly matter and prospects can make huge jumps either up or down.
Cueto is more than fair for Giolito. Giolito isnt the top guy anymore. He has been brutal this year. Urias, Glasnow, and De Leon ahead of him for sure plus maybe a few more now such as Hader, Espinoza, Bickford, Honeywell and the DBacks Cody Reed?