I think he Donaldson pinch hit was the worst move I have ever seen. If he was available he should have pinched hit with Barney on 1st. Not later in the game with 2 outs and no one on.
I think Cecil should also have gone two innings considering he had thrown 11 pitches
Is this loss on Gibby no. However as shown by the Donaldson error Gibby does not plan very well. He tends to use his bullets poorly