We need starting pitching pretty badly in the system, left handed pitching especially. Going for the guy with the highest ceiling is a good idea since drafting pitching is such a crapshoot. And you’re right, command issues can be mended in the minors.
And even if he ends up in the bullpen it’s not the end of the world. We have been desperate when it comes to left handed relievers.
But I’m not sold at McClanahan being the best player available at #12. When you draft that high you have to take the best player available. If we were drafting #20s McClanahan would be a nice gamble. But at 12 you have so many options.
If you are looking for high upside pitching, big risk big reward picks, I’d look at Carter Stewart or Cole Wilcox. Liberatore would be a dream pick. And if you’re not worried about injury concerns, Denaburg and Hankins also has electric stuff, but I personally wouldn’t gamble for them at 12.
Cole Winn would be a balance of upside and projectability.
I would rather take a flyer with a bat like Swaggerty, Kelenic, India, Lanarch, or even Gorman