Grichuk hits for power, compared to Pillar it’s not even close.
Grichuk
2016 ISO .240 HR 24
2017 ISO .235 HR 22
2018 ISO .257 HR 25
Pillar
2016 ISO .109 HR 7
2017 ISO .148 HR 16
2018 ISO .174 HR 15
Grichuk if healthy has 30 HR potential. Pillar not even close, even in his best season.
Grichuk is 27, Pillar is 30.
Every deal has risk, but unless you’re concerned about him staying healthy there’s limited evidence to suggest he won’t even be a 1 WAR player. It’s always possible a player turns into a pumpkin after signing their deal, sure. But glancing over our farm system it’s clear we don’t have many elite outfield prospects on it’s way up, they’re mostly middle infield. Having some security at a position we’re thin at, from a player just entering his prime, is not a bad thing—especially on a reasonable contract.
We had 2 more years of control so this is essentially a 3 year extension, not 5.
At some point the front office needed to make a decision on who stays and who goes, this is just the second domino following the Morales trade.