It's really early to put judgment down on Vlad. The talent is very special, in terms of what he demonstrated in the minors, his pedigree, and the raw power.
Yes it's frustrating to watch his growing pains, I totally understand you guys. It's part of the process of developing young players. But if he figures it out we're talking about a generational franchise player. You don't give up on that after just 126 MLB games, at the age of 21. It's very easy to overreact now and start pointing at his faults. That's just how the general public reacts, and it's possibly the best reason why you don't rush prospects up to the majors as fans fully expect immediate results and sour on guys if they don't produce. I don't blame you guys for acting this way, but patience is necessary for times like this.
I'm not even going to use the famous Mike Trout example, it's almost comparing apples to oranges.
There was a player that was touted as the #4 prospect by Baseball America's Top 100, he debuted as a 21-year-old, played only two games that season.
He proceeded his first season as a 22-year-old playing 43 games and hitting .215/.352/.438, OPS .790 and 101 wRC+. That's even worst than Vlad.
He struck out 28.9% and had -0.5 fWAR. Even his second season he only played 37 games hitting .165/.212/.297, OPS .509 and 26 wRC+ and -0.7 fWAR.
Utter disappointment for such a highly-touted prospect.
He switched positions from catcher to first base and two years after his debut, he finally got regular playing time as a 24-year-old and hit .270/.353/.490, OPS .843 and 111 wRC+ and 1.6 fWAR. He hit 25 home runs and 92 RBI. It was better but still a far cry from his top prospect status, especially now as a first baseman.
Most of you would DFA or trade his ass, as you are voicing for now. And this is after THREE SEASONS from his debut, let alone 1 season like Vlad Jr. You're voicing to give up on the guy and just get some value back when you can. He didn't immediately live up to his hype, in fact after 4 seasons he looks above average at best. It's certainly a bit disappointing.
Accumulated value for the first 4 seasons: 0.4 fWAR
Now, let's look at his next TEN SEASONS:
(25) .262/.350/.528, wRC+ 122, 1.8 fWAR, 30 HR
(26) .292/.385/.592, wRC+ 145, 5.7 fWAR, 38 HR
(27) .272/.377/.571, wRC+ 134, 3.6 fWAR, 44 HR
(28) .344/.470/.664, wRC+ 179, 7.4 fWAR, 41 HR <-- first time All-Star, finished 4th in AL MVP voting
(29) .279/.408/.540, wRC+ 143, 4.0 fWAR, 39 HR
(30) .277/.406/.549, wRC+ 145, 4.3 fWAR, 33 HR
(31) .302/.426/.593, wRC+ 159, 5.3 fWAR, 42 HR <-- second time All-Star, quite a travesty tbh.
(32) .269/.372/.535, wRC+ 126, 2.4 fWAR, 32 HR
(33) .301/.399/.582, wRC+ 152, 3.3 fWAR, 33 HR <-- finally changed teams
(34) .265/.361/.548, wRC+ 128, 2.8 fWAR, 38 HR <-- changed teams again
Finished career at 37 years old: 44.1 career fWAR.
He played for the Blue Jays for 12 seasons, was a 2 x All-Star, 3 x Silver Slugger, hit 473 home runs.
He is forever stapled to our level of excellence and his name is Carlos Delgado.
This is just one of many examples of guys with slow starts and why you shouldn't give up on young players.
Some of the most beloved players to put on a Blue Jays uniform didn't have a great start to their MLB careers, like Jose Bautista and Edwin Encarnacion.
Roy Halladay was another example. Patience gets rewarded and the core of this rebuild is just starting to emerge.