Makeup is a broad term that could mean a lot of different things. In terms of makeup being a douchebag, no that really doesn't make a difference. But if they have poor makeup as in a bad work eithic and/or lazy that is a thing you would want to stay away from especially when we are talking about prospects. Guys can have great talent but if they don't work hard they can easily flame out and probably do more than guys with a great work ethic.