It's a s***** situation that we have to lose one or both of these guys and that we're pitting them against each other. Sigh if only their contracts expired in 2 more years (stupid 5yr rule finally came back to bite us AA..). On the upside we know if healthy we'll get max production out of them this final contract year and it'll be fun as hell to watch! Heck maybe we win the WS and it's the perfect sendoff, or we win and Rogers Jr bites the bullet and gives them both 4-5yr deals. A lot of people would be up in arms (and rightfully so) about giving max deniero for declining value but if our beloved Jose & EE brought home a title with potential for more would it be worth it?
Although it's fun to forecast it's really hard for me to say who's going to age better statistically. Bautista is athletic and in better shape but has that violent swing and plays hard as f*** with his body finally slowing & breaking down recently as we've all witnessed. Eddy has that heavy frame (a la Big Papi) and will be protected more in an earlier DH role but he's had a myriad of fluky and irritating injuries throughout his career (unlike Ortiz) even though he's younger than Jose. Both are big game hitters although I'd probably tip my hat to Jose overall, he's a born leader and really seems to thrive off of pressure situations which is why I'm sure he'll command more money.
All I know is we've been blessed to have these two side by side all these years. Gonna be very bittersweet this year but interesting to see how it all plays out.