You must be guessing, cause you're not going by past stats. Smoak can't catch,and he's never yet proven he's above average with his bat. Navarro can catch and he's doable as a hitter, and I am not interested in the park difference, seattle bigger park should get smoak more hits but less HRs, meh, he's unremarkable as a hitter, but good defense at 1st.Thole is the one needs to go, and dickey right behind him if that's possible.