It was a bad throw by Travis as he was pretty much taken out at 2nd. Not many, if at all any, 1st basemen could catch that.
Besides, what looks more appealing on the lineup to you,
Player A: .200 BA, 35 wRC+, .250 OBP, 8.3% BB
Player B: .222 BA, 90 wRC+, .364 OBP, 18.2% BB
(SSS for both players right now I know, but one is clearly better..)