The trade was mostly lose-lose but I think the Jays still came out on top. Liriano has provided 1.2 WAR as a Blue Jay, including a great run last season and his salary hasn't been crippling to us, Hutch sucks, Ramirez is likely awful but McGuire is still a 22 year old catcher in AA, so he could yet make an okay backup in the future. At the end of the day both teams mostly forget that deal ever happened.