I really think Stroman is coming back as a starter, at least at first, for a few reasons.
1) Some of our guys (looking at you, Dickey and Buehrle) look like they might be tiring just a bit and could probably use an extra day off here and there.
2) Stroman is awesome and if there's any chance at all that he comes back and is anywhere close to as effective as he was last year (and there is), we want him in the rotation down the stretch and into the playoffs.
3) Less importantly,dude wants it so bad. Even if you don't think this should matter, I think he's viewed as such an important piece of the long-term puzzle, they'll try to keep him happy.
As of right now, he's scheduled to make two rehab starts Sept. 2 and Sept. 7, which puts him on schedule to come back Sept. 12 in New York, so here's how the rotation is shaping up heading into the Yankees series.
vs DET
Dickey (4 days rest)
Hutch (4)
Buehrle (4)
vs CLE
Price (4)
Estrada (4)
Dickey (4)
vs BAL
Hutch (5)
Price (4) *jumping ahead of MB here to keep Price on 4 days rest, give MB a breather, and have Price on schedule to pitch game 1 of the NY series*
Buehrle (6)
@BOS
Estrada (5)
Dickey (5)
Hutch (4)
@NY
Price (4)
Buehrle (4)
STROMAN (4)
Estrada (5)
So now we have six in the rotation, but at this point, we'll have seen Hutch for three starts (vs DET, vs BAL, and @BOS) to see how he does, and we have lots of options with 19 games remaining to set up the rotation for the playoffs. If Hutch sucks, we can drop him and still have five; if Estrada or Dickey implodes, same thing.
I guess what I'm getting at is what are everyone's thoughts on how Stroman fits in, 'cause he's coming fast.