Right now the players I really want for our picks 9 and 11 are Brady Aiken, Brandon Finnegan, Grant Holmes, and Luis Ortiz.
Aiken to me seems like a no-brainer AA type pick. He's one of the youngest players in the class, but he's also pretty polished with tons of experience with Team USA. He's a big lefty with low 90s velocity and a little bit more projection, a big breaking curveball and advanced command and feel. I think he's a notch below a Max Fried in terms of over all upside, but he's also more advanced than him at the same stage I think. He reminds me a bit of Tyler Skaggs from when he was drafted.
Finnegan can be either Scott Kazmir or Billy Wagner depending on whether he can stay in the rotation or has to move to the bullpen. His stuff is ridiculous from the left side. Plus-plus fastball velocity with deception cause of his delivery. He'll throw in the upper 90s through 3 innings before settling in the low to mid 90s from about the 4th inning on. There were questions about his secondaries, but if you watched any of his outings with Team USA, his slider looks like a plus pitch right now. Apparently, Rodon showed him a new grip to use, and he's been killing it with the slide piece ever since. I really like Finnegan as kind of a lefty version of Marcus Stroman. I think if he can stay in a rotation he has the stuff to be a number 2 type of starter and like Stro, he should be able to move fast up the ladder.
Holmes is just a polished high school player with very good now stuff. He doesn't have a lot of projection left given his build, but low to mid 90s with a plus slider, the feel for a change, and advanced command doesn't grow on trees. I like him because he's a relatively low risk high school player but one with still considerable upside. I think he could be a 2/3 at his peak, probably a very good 3.
Ortiz is similar to Holmes in that he doesn't have a lot of projection remaining but he has now stuff and relative polish for his age. Another guy who could be a 2/3. Kind of reminds me of an Osuna type. Him and Holmes are going to dominate the lower minors for whichever team drafts them.
Other players I like are Kodi Medeiros, but probably not at 9 or 11. The guy is flashing 3 plus pitches already if you've seen him. Scouts are saying he could pitch in the MLB right now as lefty specialist and not look out of place. The down side is his size and arm action obviously. There's big time reward with this guy IMO if you're willing to take the risk. He looks like a pretty special arm.
Ti'Quan Forbes is a name that's not getting a lot of play right now, but I've liked everything that I've seen from him. Big rangy high school shortstop. He's a big guy and might play himself off short eventually, but he looks pretty smooth there right now range wise. That bat has obvious power projection, and he shows a good approach at the plate. If you want to be super optimistic he's like Boegaerts lite. I hope he makes it to our second pick.
I love Gettys too, but everyone knows about him already. Loud tools across the board. I'll believe in the hit tool. Reminds me of Hunter Renfroe. If he starts off spring hot with the bat, and people start believing in the hit tool, he's not there at 9 anyway.
I have to say I've been really impressed by Justus Sheffield as well. I like his makeup, his confidence, and his advanced 3 pitch mix. Usually when they say a high school guy has a 3 pitch mix, they're talking about him flashing it every now and then, but Sheffield throws what consistently appear to be 3 above average pitchers in his fastball (90-94), changeup, and slider. People will probably cringe at the comparison, but he reminds me of Romero before he fell off the cliff with his command. This guy is really impressive for a high school lefty in the quality of his pitches, and shows the ability to throw all of them for strikes.