Just sign Pagan already! $3M seems to be 'the number' for FAs struggling to this OS. As long as he isn't butchering CF, he should provide league average D and has the potential to repeat his 105 RC+ in a better hitting environment/lineup.
A 1.5 WAR LF, combined with seeing less Smoak and more Pearce at 1B. All for a cheap 3M or less.