I agree, but JJ does have a 3.56 xFIP and has been victim of a high BABIP this season. He also has a 9.1 K/9 this season as well.
As for Dickey and Lawrie, yeah they've both been utter trash.
Only thing to look forward to is Stroman getting a shot late in the year now. What a disaster this season has been. 6 games under .500 through 96 games.
90% of the old forum blew up at the time of the trade. I actually remember it vividly. It was not hard to realize that this trade was going backfire big time.