I don't want to slam Carpenter, because I like him as a player. He hits for average and walks a ton, and is a good bet to score 100 runs. The flip side is he's surprisingly old, won't get 15 HR+SB, and he's about to lose 2B eligibility next year. Pujols is a far better fantasy hitter and I expect him to maintain his 130 wRC+ pace for the rest of the year, and perhaps a few more years.