I sure wouldn't.
This is one of those situations where I would throw WAR out the window. Goins is clearly a better defender, baserunner and much more versatile than JP. Goins will never have the power JP has, but he'll likely talk more walks and have better at bats. I'm not really sure where JP's value comes from but I'm not buying into it.
This doesn't mean I want Goins starting, but given the choice between Goins or JP, I'll take Goins every time.