I agree with all the pros, but everything being close is really just a byproduct of a small downtown. I do appreciate that I'm a 15-minute walk from my building on campus, less than 10 minutes away from a handful of great restaurants and bars, and a block away from the grocery store. But like I was saying, it just has that small college-town feel about it, and it's not for me. The last ~6 years I was living in Kansas City were spent in the urban core, so I'm just used to much, much more density, in both architecture, and people. The lack of tall buildings here really throws me off, which I know is a byproduct of a small city (granted, one apparently filled with yokels who hate anything tall and/or modern). The tallest building in Kingston wouldn't even crack the top 40 in Kansas City, a city not exactly known for having a large number of tall buildings. There's even a roller coaster in KC that's taller. And a World War I memorial. And a f***ing flag pole.
I lived in Ottawa until I was 15, so I was pretty young, but I don't remember any winter as bad as the one we just had in Kingston, except when we had the ice storm in (February, I think) 1998.