Nope nope nope. Hill had multiple good seasons, and even when he was s***, had two good skillsets: Defense and Baserunning
Hill was destroyed by Murphy's "Pull dat ball" mindset instead of being the line drive hitter he was. Arencibia is the same (and he was improving at some point) since coming from AAA, and not once (excluding his career debut) did I think he was good. Hill was a GG caliber All-Star, Arencibia is a twitter allstar