Smoak wRC+ 101 this year
EDIT: Upton wRC+ 99 this year
And Edwin is adequate at 1B
Gives Gibby some flexibility anyway... but he seems to like Smoak a bit more than maybe he should rationally
Upton and Pillar can cover a lot of gound
But you want Bautista AND Saunders' bats both in the lineup
Hence, my likiness of this lineup from Gibby today