It's a lottery, it really is. I have full faith that multiple members of this board would be better GMs than Anthopoulos, and that's not even necessarily due to the intelligence of the members.
He's actually cost us a solid 2.5 wins (which, with framing, could be closer to 3.5) through wRAA, BsR and Fld. Literally the only thing that he does at an MLB level is show up. It's remarkable.