What a horrid piece of analysis. Nobody before 2010 was AA's pick. Deck was a s***** pick in his first year as GM. Beede didn't sign and went higher or in a similar place in which he was originally drafted IIRC. Davis was taken in the same year as Stroman and missed. Bickford is going to go like top 10 this year and negotiated in bad faith. He found 3 guys that were really good (Beede, Bickford, Stroman) and missed on two (McGuire, Davis). A 60% success rate combined with an incredible job of finding late picks like Boyd and Graveman and Pompey and comp guys like Sanchez, Syndergaard, etc as well as IFAs like Barreto and Castro and Osuna makes him more than adequate. AA and his staff would make a sick farm team. It's just the MLB part he struggles with (minor detail). To say that our players don't develop is short sighted. You're getting confused with simple prospect attrition.