When the Blue Jays and Dodgers First Met

[Mac]

Carlos Tosca was starting to rethink things.

The Blue Jays were 20-33 when first-year general manager J.P. Ricciardi relieved Buck Martinez of his managerial duties at the start of June, replacing him with Tosca. Toronto responded by winning seven of their first eight games under their new skipper, but having just been walked off by Mike Mordecai in Montreal, the team had now lost five in a row, and the schedule wasn’t getting easier. Toronto’s interleague road trip would continue in Los Angeles and Arizona, facing the two teams fighting at the top of the National League West.

This would be the Blue Jays’ first ever trip to Chavez Ravine. Interleague play began in ‘97, but Major League Baseball changed scheduling in 2002, making this the first year Toronto played teams outside of the NL East. Action between the two leagues had started earlier in the month, and the Blue Jays had swept the Rockies at home and beat the Giants before dropping the next two to San Francisco to start the current slide. So Tosca plotted his next move, perhaps emboldened by the success of his first.

When he took over, Tosca said he would make better use of every player on the Blue Jays. For Chris Woodward, any use would be better use. It would be generous to say Martinez played him sparingly. In Buck’s second-to-last game on June 2, Woodward started for only the sixth time at shortstop in place of scuffling starter Felipe López. The previous month, he had appeared in only five games. Since Tosca began writing the lineup cards, Woodward matched his season total with six more starts and got a hit in every single one. All Woodward wanted was a manager to give him a chance to play every day, and unbeknownst to him, Tosca was that manager.

Woodward had led off on a Shannon Stewart off day in the previous series, and Tosca would now feature his new-everyday shortstop at the top of his regular lineup card. Batting behind Woodward would be rookie Eric Hinske, up from the fifth spot, slashing .278/.367/.532 to this point in the year. Stewart would hit third, moving Raúl Mondesí to fifth behind the ever-in-place Carlos Delgado at cleanup. Putting his top on-base guys in front of Delgado and Mondesí was what drove the change, Tosca said. That was true, but the manager was also being delicate with one player, expecting to hear it in his return to Dodger Stadium.

Batting	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS
Carlos Delgado	.256	.401	.530	.931
Tom Wilson	.268	.377	.431	.808
Eric Hinske	.278	.367	.532	.899
Shannon Stewart	.290	.342	.438	.780
Chris Woodward	.281	.339	.632	.970
José Cruz	.227	.306	.385	.690
Felipe López	.234	.300	.416	.716
Raúl Mondesí	.218	.295	.432	.728
Vernon Wells	.249	.294	.397	.691
Dave Berg	.247	.275	.367	.642
Darrin Fletcher	.218	.241	.307	.548

Blue Jays OBP leaders leading up to the game on June 18, 2002, provided by Baseball-Reference.com (view original table).

Mondesí was unwelcome. Again. He had his share of detractors in his last season as a Dodger, hounded for off-field behaviour and even smeared in the media by the team before he was dealt to Toronto for Shawn Green. Things had gotten so bad between Mondesí, Green, and their respective teams that then-Toronto GM Gord Ash allowed Jeff Moorad, the agent for both players, to work out the details of a trade. It took Mondesí a while to get over the move, but he thought he would at least be joining a contender with the Blue Jays, and hey, Ash guaranteed the final two years of his contract. It wasn’t going to be so bad in Toronto.

Had his predecessor not done that, Ricciardi would have been fine with walking away from Mondesí upon taking over the team. Mondesí had hit 27 home runs and stolen 30 bases in 2001, but the new general manager was doing anything he could to move off the $24 million Ash committed to the right fielder over the next two seasons. It had been a directive from the new Rogers ownership, and Ricciardi was wishing he had found a taker. Mondesí's play hit a clear downturn in ‘02, and he was almost untradeable. Before the game, Mondesí spoke fondly about his time as a Dodger, fondly on his future elsewhere and... little about Toronto. “I want a World Series ring,” Mondesí said. “You want to win. I enjoy Toronto, but I would play the same wherever I went.”

Booed by the crowd of 24,991 before his first at-bat, Mondesí wasn’t shaken, saying the fans jeered “because they have to. I know inside the fans don’t feel that way. These are the best fans in the world.” He was traded to the Yankees in July for a minor league arm, a salary dump in which Toronto was able to offload some of the remaining debt. I’m sure this too, Raúl, was written as a letter of love about your time with the Yankees. (photo credit: The Toronto Sun)

By far the strongest part of Tosca’s lineup would be in the nine spot. Roy Halladay arrived from day one in 2002. He threw at least seven innings in his first four starts and ripped off a stretch of five straight wins in May. He was on his way to his first All-Star Game, but Doc had a blip in his last outing, leaving in the seventh inning, having surrendered five runs on 10 hits to the Giants. No matter that, Halladay had just entered the era of Doc, who was exactly the pitcher you wanted to stop a losing streak. Tosca could expect his pitcher to be an ace against the Dodgers, but he would end up asking him to do way, way too much in a National League ballpark.

After a scoreless first inning, a walk and a stolen base had José Cruz on second with one out against Dodgers starter Andy Ashby. Up next, Joe Lawrence hit a bloop single, but a cautious Brian Butterfield held Cruz at third base out of respect for Green’s arm in right. The press box at Dodger Stadium derided the stop sign with the light-hitting Ken Huckaby coming to the plate. Runs were going to be at a premium tonight, but Toronto’s catcher stepped up to deliver home Cruz for the first run of the game. Huckaby's single left runners on the corners for Halladay with still one away.

Far from the hitter who delivered an RBI base hit in the playoffs, Halladay had six career plate appearances coming into this game. He had struck out three times, moved runners over against Orel Hershiser and Steve Trachsel, and even managed a groundout against Trachsel. After Halladay swung through the first pitch from Ashby, Tosca acted on an idea. He signaled to Butterfield, who relayed the information to Lawrence at third and Doc at the plate. Somewhere along the chain, someone must have wondered, ‘Is this right?’

As Ashby broke from set, Lawrence took off, and Doc squared around. It was an absurd time to call for the squeeze, and you've got to miss this era of baseball. The pitch from Ashby was outside, eluding the bunt attempt into the mitt of Dodgers catcher Paul Lo Duca, who tagged a dead duck in Lawrence. Halladay inevitably struck out, but had Tosca not inserted himself into the game, he would have given Woodward a chance with runners on the corners. Those had to be the opportunities the manager had been speaking of, right? As Toronto trotted out for the home half of the second with the lead, they would not be joined by Woodward, who was replaced by Lopez at short. The squeeze call may have been in response to whatever was going on with Woodward.

Semi-rewind to Shea Stadium on June 7, 1999. Halladay would step to the plate for the first time in his career against the Mets that night, and it was also the major league debut of Woodward, who drove in the only two runs in an 8-2 defeat on a not-yet-that-Doc night for the Blue Jays. Manager Jim Fregosi, days from getting clocked in the face, joked Woodward could hit cleanup instead of Tony Fernandez, who was reluctantly doing so at the time. For the Toronto Star’s Dave Perkins, at least the call-up of Woodward would mean the end of Homer Bush at shortstop in ‘99, or what he called “a jerry-rigged exercise in futility for 18 games.” (photo credit: Aaron Harris/CP/Sportsnet)

Nonetheless, Jim Tracy was left inspired. In his second season as manager of the Dodgers, Tracy had yet to meet Paul DePodesta, with whom he’d clash over the incoming general manager’s sabermetric leanings. Tosca would not upstage Tracy in smallball. Not in his ballpark, dammit. With one out and Ashby at the plate, former Blue Jay César Izturis stole third base. With the count 1-2, Tracy called for his own squeeze! Ashby was able to make contact with the pitch, fouling it off to strike out but keep Izturis and the inning alive. Facing the top of the order, Halladay used three pitches to retire Dave Roberts on a groundout to end the third inning. 

In spite of ridiculous instructions at the plate, Doc was magic on the mound all night. The only other runs of the ballgame were attested to Delgado: an RBI double in the sixth off the bat of the Blue Jays' slugger and an error in the eighth that led to a run on a base hit from Green. It was the lone blemish on Halladay’s night, the fifth of many complete game victories to come in his career. He threw 67 strikes on an even 100-pitch night, allowing just four hits and the unearned run. Doc walked two and struck out seven; he was sharp, but he wanted to be exact, saying the “last pitch (to Green) could have been a little lower to give him a harder time with it, but he is just a great hitter.”

Woodward’s absence from the final eight innings was due to a pulled groin he suffered before the game while taking infield. It was especially crushing as Woodward, who grew up nearby, had over 30 people in the crowd to watch him in the majors for the first time. The injury would keep him on the shelf for weeks, and when he returned in July, Lopez remained no threat to him in the eyes of Tosca. Woodward played most days, and with Mondesí traded and Cruz injured, he even served as the segue three-hole hitter to Vernon Wells, who took the spot for good in the last game of August. It was the best season of Woodward’s career (2.3 bWAR), and he would stay with the Jays until ‘04 before returning for 11 games at the end of his career in 2011.

The 2-1 victory was Toronto’s only win in their first trip to Dodger Stadium. They got the door shut on them by Éric Gagné the next two nights, but things stayed better under Tosca. The Jays finished 59-51 on their way to a somewhat improbable 78-win season. Tosca had stayed true and continued to play the entirety of his roster. Another beneficiary was Josh Phelps, who kept hitting upon his call-up in July, and Tosca kept writing him into the lineup. Phelps slashed .309/.362/.562 in 287 plate appearances, finishing sixth in the AL Rookie of the Year race behind Hinske, who finished the year hitting second in Tosca’s lineups.

View full article