Here's an excellent read on Cobb and about the real criminal Al Stump fabricating everything he could in Cobb's biography that became the movie we know today.... Charles Leerhsen set most of that hot garbage straight.
https://imprimis.hillsdale.edu/who-was-ty-cobb-the-history-we-know-thats-wrong/
Highly recommend to read it.
Love em both, but it's close, here's Callis video inbox on this very question... I agree with you 3.
https://www.mlb.com/video/comparing-tatis-jr-bichette/c-1870488783?tid=26271672