Atkins made a terrible decision when he decided to go all in on pitching and defence at the expense of hitting. It's like playing the trap in hockey. The only time it's not a miserable experience is if you win it all.
2023 was the year to go for it. We had the expiring contracts. A few years left of control on Bo and Vlad, and a solid starting rotating, It was a natural year to roll the dice and go for it all while this year would have been the natural year to retool and evaluate where to go next. All Atkins needed to do was bring back the same team from 2022 while shoring up the bullpen and buying bullpen arms at the deadline is usually easier and cheaper than getting a great bat.
Instead Shatkins went all galaxy brain. The Jays blew the best year of the Bo and Vlad era and now have years of control of a team that will be lucky to make the playoffs and is no fun to watch. Funny thing is Atkins actually had the opportunity to right the ship a bit by bringing back Teo or Gurriel this offseason but failed there too.