Hi all!
I am a newbie on this forum, but a huge fan of the Jay for years. I just wanted to weigh in on this, mainly because I can't fathom the replies that I am reading.
For one, to say that Chapman will not be suspended because the Yankees have him is just umm not true. It should not matter which team has him. It won't matter which team has him.
Two, for those who say he should not be suspended because no charges were laid and these are allegations, I have seen a lot of people (myself included) in the real world, lose their job because of allegations. If this were not the case in MLB, why have the policy in the first place.
Three, even if there are no charges, if MLB does not investigate it and if action is warrranted, suspend him, what message does that send to their female fan base? You better believe that will be a consideration. Maybe the NFL could care less because there are less female fans there than males, but MLB sure will.
Four, the criminal investigation is not over now. The prosecutor and DA are now looking into the matter and can bring charges regardless of what the police did. I do not profess to know USA criminal law (and never will!) however if this occurred in Canada, I know it would not be swept under the rug. I can think of the following:
1. Careless use of a firearm
2. Careless storage of a firearm
3. Assault with a firearm
These are all Criminal Code charges that he could face if he did this in Canada. He would probably get around 5-10 years in prison, as some of these are at minimum 3 years (even for an athlete!)
Regardless, even if he is charged in the USA eventually, that can definitely affect his ability to cross the border into Canada. If he is convicted, chances are he will never be allowed to enter Canada. Therefore, 2 things can be noted: 1) If he is a Yankee, he won't be going on Toronto road trips and 2) This would be a huge reason why the Jays would not try and get him.
I get that he is a good, hard throwing, pitcher. However, someone who is accused of this and goes and just fires his gun randomly in his garage (with one bullet going through the window, which could have killed someone once it passed through the window) is not exactly a "stand up citizen". I am one person, at least here, that hopes that MLB throws the book at him and hopes he faces justice in a court of law and if found guilty, gets a long prison sentence, not a slap on the wrist because of who he is.
This is about more than baseball, this is a person's conduct and the safety of others.