Except you need to have elite player development. You think Noah would be anywhere near where he is now right here? I mean, when we traded him, he was pretty raw. He could throw 100 but didn't have the greatest secondary stuff and din't even have a 3rd pitch. No guarantee he develops the same way here. I mean, before probably Stroman, the last homegrown star we had was Hill. Hell, look at Arrieta in Baltimore vs Arrieta now. As for Hoffman... he doesn't have much deception and can't really strike anyone out with the lack of deception in his new delivery forced onto him which is much like Sanchez's delivery (which, obviously, is not very conducive to strikeouts) by us. Those K numbers haven't exactly shot up in Colorado's farm either. Oh, speaking of, Hoffman has now managed to go to an organization that is horrendous at pitcher development. I can guarantee you he doesn't reach his potential while he's with the Rockies. Hech cannot hit to save his life, he is absolute trash with the bat. Lawrie and Gose are undisciplined toolsy nightmares. Those guys... they could've been developed better in our system but haven't done anything elsewhere either. Speaking of Gose, our best position player to come up from the minors since Hill is Travis. That's it. That's how bad our player development is when our best player that came up was completely developed by another organization.
It takes elite player development and drafting... you wonder how the Cards are able to replace almost everyone that gets hurt or leaves nearly seamlessly? They are great at drafting and even better at developing. We may do well drafting, but our player development is s***. I mean, our only homegrown star pitcher since Doc being Stroman and our only hitting prospect to translate well to the bigs since Hill being Travis? Pathetic.
That said, once more, I think AA does a really good job at drafting, but really needs to overhaul player development IMO.