In:
Donaldson, Martin, Saunders, Travis, Smoak, Estrada
Out:
Lawrie, Graveman, Nolin, Baretto, Gose, Happ, Rasmus, Melky, Morrow, Janssen, Navarro (likely), Lind.
Not so amazing. Esp when you look at guys like Rasmus, Lawrie, Melky, and Morrow as guys with potential to have performed a LOT better than they did during the 2014 season.
From a potential stand point, taking the highest WAR the above players posted in 2013 and 2014 (and 2012 for injury riddled players) we get
In:
Donaldson, Martin, Saunders, Travis, Smoak, Estrada
8+5.5+2.4+(Replacement)+1.4+1.6= 18.9
Out:
Lawrie, Gose, Happ, Rasmus, Melky, Morrow, Janssen, Navarro (likely), Lind.
4.5 (2012)+ (Replacement)+ 1.4 + 4.6 + 3.1 + 3.2 (2012) + 1.4 + 2.3 + 2.3= 22.8
Didn't count Pompey as I feel he is a prospect and doesn't count as an addition even though the departure of Rasmus opens up a spot for him. He could have been traded if we held onto Rasmus.