Where you go next year depends also on Bautista, Edwin, and Saunders. If those guys are gone, the offense wont be good enough to compete with the Os and Sox
Lineup will be
Upton
Donaldson
Travis
Tulo
Martin
Smoak
Pillar
Pompey?
Random DH
Taking those guys out of the lineup, will probably close the competing window. A that point you might as well move Donaldson and Rebuild. In that case, you can try to start Osuna. However if Jose and Saunders are back, then you can extend your competition window
Upton
Donaldson
Bautista as DH
Tulo
Saunders
Travis
Martin
Pillar
Pompey
Now you can go out there and get a starter and add to the 4 good ones we have. Then leave Osuna in the pen, and try to win again
We can win without Edwin.