Call the splits dumb all you want, but they gotta be telling you something.
In fact, during this "previous 3 year" sample that you arbitrarily decided to pick, Colby's OBP was a combined .306....It's just not that great at the end of the day when you've got a guy like Gose who is a much cheaper option than Rasmus, and has a higher propensity to get on base... Not to mention the team's winning % is much higher when Gose plays. I'd sacrifice the odd home run if it meant we're keeping rallies going and staying on the base paths.