All you have to do is look at Tulos reaction to Pillar almost running into him again,after he comes back from his injury.
Tulo was glaring at him,so from then on,to me it looks like whoever seems the most sure they have it,should catch the ball.
Goins ran half a mile to get to the ball,and convinced Bautista he had it all the way,otherwise Bautista would have kept going for it.Goins f***ed up because he knew all along that should have been Bautistas ball in the first place,when afterwards he asks JB if he called for it.
Rookie mistake in his first ALCS.
They will(hopefully), flush it down the toilet,and move on.