Platoons are never ideal over one player who can play everyday at the position.
Last 3 years of Reddick gets you this vs Lhp 202ave, 265 obp, 534ops\ Rhp 249 Ave, 305 obp, 714 ops
Total 258ave, 313 obp, 734 ops for 12 - 17 mil and I need a platoon partner to play and pay to boot.
Angel pagen might cost less and has a better fielding percentage in all fields career wise and is a switch hitter who has stolen 43 bases over the last 3 years. Doesn't need a platoon partner, ya dig?
Last 3 years vs Lhp 275ave, 311obp, 689ops / Rhp 279ave, 330 obp, 709 ops total 278ave, 324 obp, 702ops