If you were AA circa late 2012 and you had the chance to bring a NL CY winning pitcher, two other NL pitchers with perennial front of the rotation stuff, a NL batting champion with speed as your lead off hitter, and another potential NL batting champion rehabbing his image fresh off a steroid suspension would you do it? Bring all these players to a team that was relatively competitive and seemingly a few pieces away from taking over the AL East from the aging Red Sox & Yankees, would you make these deals? Before going apeshit please take into consideration that hindsight is always 20/20 and it's easy now to see that he should've used his money elsewhere given the results but at that time was it really so predictable that this move would implode? I admit there were injury concerns with a few of these players but would you have taken the gamble..
Given the Jays position in late 2012 was AA justified in making these moves in spite of injury concerns or was his fatal error seriously misjudging the transition needed from these NL superstars coming over to the AL East, arguably the toughest division in baseball. Should he have sought high caliber players from within the AL? And would that have made a huge difference as all these players have struggled with the AL East transition except Melky (who ironically at the time was seen as the biggest gamble) and perhaps to a lesser degree Buehrle who like the Melkman also had past AL experience.
Again please take into consideration your feelings at the time of the trade instead of your present day bitterness, I'll admit that I for one was over the moon when it happened. Heck all the supposed pros in Vegas even had this team pegged as the overwhelming favorite to win the WS. Was AA justified in his rationale to overthrow the division in spite of the incoming injury concerns or was the massive flaw the Inter league transition struggles that he didn't foresee, thoughts?