Arash Madani came on shortly after the incident and he mentioned that you get charged on mischief, it gets put on your criminal record, you have to pay a "substantial fine" and spend a night in jail.
Smoak to this point last season had a 122 wRC+ fueled by a .400 BABIP, striking out 29.8% and walking 13.5% of the time. His ISO was .149.
Smoak this season is better at everything except walking and his BABIP is substantially lower/way more sustainable, at .294
You're both wrong, defensive stats historically have Votto as a very good defender at first. He had an outlier last season, those unfortunately happen, but is now back to being well above average.