Dude, nobody's saying that, lets see what he does next season repeating AA, he's been alright as a 20 year old, I'm assuming we'll see positive regression. Sano was far better at 22 in AA... Wow!
Decent read of Maddon on analytics and FO's interfering in game management etc, click the link...
Much ado about this FO, me thinks. I'm really not sure Montoyo and Schneider has much say.