Okay while watching the basketball game, I just attempted to deduce the offers like I did with the grant/chappy offer in the premier league. I need to find a better hobby for my free time...
Eliminate: KK, Myself, Spanky -- for obvious reasons ITT.
Eliminate: Boxy, Havok, jaysfever -- all have made it clear they aren't competing this year. AGonz wouldn't suit them.
Eliminate: z3r0s -- he made it clear he's happy with his 1B situation and is even trying to trade a 1B.
Eliminate: jaysblue -- he already has a logjam of Napoli, Teixeira, Freeman
Eliminate: dinger, torontofan, BTS, North, hurl -- you can never really count dinger out, but all 5 of these guys have 1B/UTIL blocked with two 1Bs/3Bs.
Eliminate: realmin -- Cuddyer is hurt, but should be back soon. OF/UTIL of Jones/Stanton/Holliday/Rios. No room for AGonz.
Eliminate: silvergun -- 1B/OF/UTIL filled with Morneau/Jackson/CarGo/Upton/Bruce. Pretty loaded.
Eliminate: gibbers -- he could still be in play. He doesn't have a true 1B and has some good young MLB arms. None fit the bill of the "big time prospect" though. Doesn't seem like a gibbers move.
Eliminate: njh -- he has a couple arms who could fit the bill, but he has Davis/Hart. I predict he's more than content with that 1B/UTIL combo and wouldn't want to part with any of his pitching.
Lastly, eliminate: sammy -- He has votto, but has room at UTIL. It looks like he could use the offensive boost too. If it's Sammy it has to be Gray/Wacha. Neither fit the "big time prospect bill" when they were being brought up, and my gut says Sammy would keep them. I eliminate him, but he would be the 3rd guess for me.
That leaves: CatsAss and SpeedyGose.
Cats has Abreu/Gomez/Hamilton/Puig/Martin. That's pretty crowded, but Hammy is hurt, and he's shown he's not afraid to immediately flip players. The main reason I speculate it's Cats is because he has Skaggs who fits KK's description perfectly.
Speedy has Swisher as his 1B and some room in his OF. AGonz would fill a major hole for him. He also has Kyle Zimmer and Robert Stephenson sitting in his farm. Both are top 20 prospects.
Both are in win-now mode and have players who would make sense based on the info given. The secondary pieces could be anything, but I predict the offers are something like:
Cats offers: Tyler Skaggs + 14th overall + C prospect
Speedy offers: One of Kyle Zimmer/Robert Stephenson + 8th overall + C prospect
*Darkhorse hail mary prediction: BTS throws Syndergaard KK's way.