He already has 65 WAR and looks to have a few good years left at least. Could reach 3000 hits and 450 home runs. Amazing glove reputation and the counting numbers look good for him making it.
Cabrera: 387/459/685 (think this didnt update for tonight so May 22)
Bautista: 353/500/816 (May 22, 2011)
Don't remember Jose getting near the amount of headlines.
Could be bad for his confidence if he gets knocked around a little. The pressure would be enormous for a pitcher who would jump 3 levels. Rick Ankiel comes to mind if you know his story.